Order an Ice Cream Pie

Starting at $28.99 CAD

Our famous ice cream pies are handmade with fresh Island dairy and topped just the way you like them. Please place your order 24–36 hours in advance.

Choose your base, pick your toppings (max 3), and let us know if you’d like a gluten-free or dairy-free option. We’ll have your pie ready to pick up fresh at Cricker’s Creamery in Rustico.

Choose Your Base(Required)

Vanilla

Chocolate

Swirl (Vanilla + Chocolate)

Topping 1(Required)

Chocolate sauce is included. Hot fudge and hot caramel are specialty toppings.

Topping 2 (optional)

Topping 3 (optional)

Ice Cream Pie

Price:

Gluten-Free or Dairy-Free Options

Quantity

Your Name(Required)

Email(Required)

Phone(Required)

Preferred Pick-Up Date(Required)

Please give us 24–36 hours advance notice.

Special Requests / Notes

Total

Please order 24–36 hours in advance.

Online ordering coming July 2026. For now, please call us at (902) 360-2010 to place your order.